You are here

Action alert:

Nuclear Monitor Issue: 
#320
03/11/1989
Article

demand to the European Parliament to shut down Superphenix 

(November 3, 1989) On 1 September the Superphenix reactor at Creys-Malville, France, which suffered severe damage in 1987, received a license to continue operation. The Superphenix is a prototype 1250 MW Fast Breeder requiring components so huge that they could not be tested to scale prior to going into operation. Superphenix is a joint European enterprise. Participants include France (51%), Italy (33%), West Germany (11.02%), Belgium (2.36%), Holland (2.36%) and Great Britain (0.26%). It is situated between Geneva and Lyon, not far from the Swiss and Italian border. Five million people live within a radius of 100 km. On pages 9 and 10 of this issue, we have reprinted a petition requesting the European Parliament to demand the shut down of the Superphenix. Please sign and circulate this petition and return it to the Association de Femmes Pour La Survie Information Sur Les Dangers Du Nucleaire (their address is on the petition). Time is short. It must be sent back before 30 November. For more information on the Superphenix, contact also: Contratom, Case Postale 107, CH-1227 Carouge, Switzerland.


L'Avenir est notre affaire


ASSOCIATION DE FEMMES POUR LA SURVIE INFORMATION SUR LES DANGERS DU NUCLEAIRE
- notamment le Superphénix de Creys-Malville -

Le Comité

Princess Catherine

Ago Khan Fondation de Bellerive

Monique Bauer-Lagier
Anc. députée au Conseil des Etats à Bern.,
anc. président de l'Ass. des Parlementaires de Langue Française

Marlene Belilos
Journalist. it enseignante
Conseillère municipale

Jacqueline Berenstein-Wavre
President. du Grand Conseil do Canton d. Geneve

Francoise Chappaz
Secrétaire générale do WWF-Genève

Laurence Deonna
Ecrivain - reporter
prix Unesco 1987 pour l'Education a paix Paris
Medaglia d'oro per la pace 1988
Rome

Ella Maillart Voyageus. - ócrivain
prix de la Ville de Geneve 1987
Science, humaines

Nanik-Denis de Rougemont
Ecologiste

Theresa Sursock
Mère de famille

Erika Sutter
Depute.

Marguerite Wieser
Ancienne président de l'Ecole de traduction
et d'interprétation de l'Université de Geneva

URGENT PETITION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT

We, women of Europe and of the World, deeply worried by

  • the experts' contradictory declarations regarding fast-breeder nuclear reactors,
  • the consequences of a possible accident,
  • the faulty functioning of the Superphenix reactor at Creys-Malville, France, the only fast-breeder of industrial size in the world, which has been put into operation despite an appeal launched in 1976 by 1326 scientists, including 400 physicists from the European Organisation for Nuclear Research (CERN),

request the European Parliament:

  1. TO DEMAND THAT SUPERPHENIX BE CLOSED DOWN
    Superphenix is a PROTOTYPE 1 250 MW FAST-BREEDER. It is the most powerful in the world (5 times more powerful than its predecessor Phenix).

    In conventional Pressurized Water Reactors (PWR) and Boiling Water Reactors (BWR) the neutrons are slowed down by the water, which acts as a moderator, to speeds of a few kilometers per second. In a fast breeder the slowing down process is avoided by cooling the reactor with liquid sodium instead of water. The neutrons reach speeds of some 50000 kilometers per second. This is necessary in order to create more fissionable material (i.e. plutonium) than is consumed in energy production.

    Superphenix contains FIVE TONS OF PLUTONIUM. A traditional plant contains only a few hundred kilos. A FEW MICROGRAMS OF INHALED PLUTONIUM are enough to cause lung CANCER. The half-life of plutonium is 24,000 YEARS.

    Superphenix needs 5,000 TONS OF SODIUM as a cooling agent. A traditional reactor uses water. Sodium CATCHES FIRE when it comes into contact with air and EXPLODES when it comes into contact with water. At present, only fires involving a few hundred kilos can be brought under control.

    Promoting a nuclear plant of this type tends to create a centralised technosphere in disharmony with the survival of the biosphere. It challenges democratic values, denying citizens the basic rights to choose their way of life and to be informed;
     

  2. TO MAKE THE GRANTING OF AUTHORITY TO OPERATE this reputedly dangerous plant subject to the conclusion of appropiate international agreements and conventions between the countries owning the plant and neighbouring states directly concerned in view of their geographic proximity;
     
  3. TO ORGANISE AN INFORMATION CAMPAIGN AT EUROPEAN LEVEL ON ENERGY SAVING, aimed at reducing present consumption by 20 to 30%;
     
  4. TO BRING ALL CONCERNED PARTIES TOGETHER FOR PUBLIC DEBATE on the implications of nuclear technology, particularly with regard to Superphenix; At such a debate, the following questions should be examined:
    1. What factors prompted most nations possessing small experimental prototypes of such reactors to stop developing and using them?
    2. Is the fast-breeder technology compatible with democratic rights to information, liberty of expression and decision?
    3. Is it acceptable, when the safety of millions is at stake, that only short-term economic criteria, questions of prestige and military applications should be taken into consideration ?
    4. What account should be taken of declarations and warnings emanating from numerous scientists, physicists (particularly at CERN) and Nobel prize-winners who have stated their oposition to fast-breeder technology?

The dangers surrounding this technology surpass any yet faced by our planet. They threaten an important part of Europe which, as Jack Steinberger, 1 988 Nobel prize-winner, recently stated, << could be transformed into a desert for an unlimited period of time>>.

THE FUTURE IS OUR BUSINESS - IT IS ALSO YOURS!

CASE POSTALE 229 - CH-1 211 GENEVE 12 - TEL. 4122/733 68 68 et 477 032 LE MATIN)
COMPTE DE CHÈQUES POSTAUX - GENEVE CCP 12-224896 - COMPTE BANCAIRE: CAISSE DEPARGNE DU CANTON DE GENEVE No E.807 966